When Dad Says: “Try a Cheese Sandwich”

My dad practiced law and he told me when I started, “You need to try a lot of cases so you get good at trial work” and have a “bite with your bark”. He said, “you go try everything, try a cheese sandwich”.  So, early in my career I suffered several losses at the courthouse and wondered why.  Was I not any good at trying cases? I tried a bunch of auto injury cases back in the 1990’s. I remember twice having back to back jury trials, that is; a jury goes out to deliberate a case and while they were in the jury room I picked another jury and started a second jury trial right then, same day, same court room, different client different defense attorney. When the jury from the first case had a verdict, we stopped the second case, excused that jury for break and got the verdict from the first jury. Well, when I had lost several trials I had to go back and look and analyze what happened. That was when I figured it out. My problem had been case selection. I was trying some cases that were like my dad’s “cheese sandwich”. Let me share one of them with you and perhaps it will make you smile. My client had borrowed his sister’s car and he did not have a driver’s license, never had one, never been a licensed driver. He left skid marks from his lane into the oncoming lane of travel. That is right, there was evidence he left his lane of travel and entered the lane of the oncoming car. The photos I had from the scene, which showed the skid marks, also showed a house in the background with a lady in a rocker on the front porch. She was listed on the police report as a witness. She had been in that same rocker on that same porch the day the accident happened, and she said my client drove into the oncoming lane of travel hitting the other car, consistent with the skid marks. I know, I know, your reading it right… a witness and physical evidence demonstrating my client was the one who caused the collision.  Obviously an extremely hard case to win, my client was at fault, what was I thinking……. I know, “try a cheese sandwich”